NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUPEpic Ink Liner, Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner - Black, Vegan Formula

I mean what can I say about these that you don't already know...they're the BEST liquid liners in the game! I will splurge on high end products, especially when they're worth it. I used to use the Stila black liquid liner, I used it for years but then I noticed that the formula had changed and it wasn't as long wearing, vibrant, and smudge proof as it was previously. At $24 a pen it had better be darn good eyeliner! So I went on the hunt for another eyeliner that would live up to my expectations. I bought this at Wal-Mart when I was broke and figured it would get me through till payday when I had some more expensive brands already eyeballed out to buy... I've never bought another kind since! They're BETTER than Stila was before. It's matte, waterproof, BUILDABLE! One of the only brands of liquid liner I've come across (and I've come across MANY...) that layers well on top of itself. And I always have to do this because I always make one eye perfect and the other eye is inferior so I have to increase the wingspan, back and forth, until I look like Amy Winehouse. What I'm TRYING to say it's forgiving of human error. Lots of errors. The texture is PERFECT, if you're a minimalist and enjoy a lil' baby wing, it's perfectly black (not opaque at all) with one swipe. The tip allows you a tremendous amount of control, you can have the THINNEST line, or go as dramatic and bold as your creativity allows without worry of taking off the bottom layer if you have to do corrections. I may spend $53 on my foundation, but NYX has the market on liquid liner. If you're buying high end, WHY?? This is better for literally $10 a pen! Stockpile! Lord knows I am! JUST DON'T BUY THEM ALL!

I have always used MAC liquid black eyeliner. I thought that I might try this liner, not sure why. The richness of the color black when I first put it on was not as dark as what I was accustomed to, but when it dried, it was amazing. The color dried to almost rhe same ruch black that i have been used to. The product stayed on all day without smearing or smudging. Definitely happy that I tried this and will be using this from now on.

I've tried a lot of different liquid eyeliner. As someone who wears eyeliner basically everyday in a thick wing - I need something that'll last. I'm so happy with this eyeliner! I've had it for two months now and it has not dried out. It does tend to smudge towards the end of the day but nothing a touch up won't fix. I only had an issue with it leaking when I got off an airplane but it wasn't a big deal. The applicator is perfect for getting a slick wing every time!

I’ve been using this eyeliner for years and it’s the best I’ve found out of your basic affordable eyeliners. It goes on smooth and doesn’t easily smudge. It’s not waterproof, at all. Once the liner starts to get close to the end of its lifespan it will start to bubble at the tip and risk the liner getting in your eye if you aren’t careful, it’s like the tip is bleeding heavier than usual. Not sure why it does this, but it’s happened to every single one I’ve ever bought. It’s still usable when this happens, it’s just annoying. I usually replace it at this point.

I love this eyeliner. I use to use Stila, but when it gets too hot, I would get sweaty and the eyeliner just wipes off. I used this eyeliner during 100 F weather in Philippines, and it DID NOT BUDGE. But it will still wipe off if going in water, but still great for use if I am not going to the pool/beach.

This eyeliner is the BEST. I looked for reviews online because I’ve been spending too much money on eyeliners that I don’t like or finish over and over. This one came up repeatedly. So glad I bought it.I will buy this forever until they discontinue it.

The marker tip makes a great thin line and it’s easy to build thickness as desired. I like the brown color and amount of pigment. I’ve used stila in the past and prefer this because it lasts longer without drying out.

The color of this liquid eyeliner is spot on. Give this a few shakes and you are ready to go with creating amazing patterns on your eye lid.However, it doesn’t stay on super long as it is not water resistant. As well, it leaks a lot from itself and gets all over your hands while using it. I put the cap on to prevent it from drying and the ink splattered everywhere including my shirt. Use with caution.